Skip to main content

Statistical Analysis Trainer

AI
Education
Instructional Design
Statistics
An AI-based statistical analysis training tool
Published

November 11, 2026

The problem

It can be difficult to learn a new technology, particularly one involved with finicky technical work such as statistics. AI, when properly used, can be immensely valuable in helping a student learn a new technology, and is able smooth the learning process out, helping to break down syntax, decode error messages, and identify coding bugs. This particular project was born from a self-study strategy I used personally to get a handle on the statistical language R, as well as adapting my workflow to more appropiately address the needs of students.

For students learning a new language, we want a workflow that enables students to learn independently, while keeping the responsibility for learning firmly on the student’s shoulders.

Design rationale

For new students learning game design and attempting to create their own games, a common adage is “finish a game as quickly as possible”. It’s important for a new learner to see all stages of game design to gain a better understanding of game design as a holistic process. When learning a new statistical langauge and learning how to perform a statistical analysis, it is useful to use a similar approach, and this trainer is an attempt to build a workflow to get a student producing a minimum viable statistical analysis in their language of choice as quickly as possible and then checking the quality of that analysis against a vetted reference analysis.

Following principles of good design, we divide the workflow into two distinct stages, a planning stage and a reveal stage. Each stage begins with a new AI instance and has its own dedicated AI orientation documents and student briefs. The planning stage AI recieves its orientation document, the experimental design description, and the dataset. The reveal stage AI receives its own orientation document, the experimental design description, the dataset, as well as the solution key and the student’s statistical report. This way each stage is kept independent, and the planning AI is unable to easily give away any information to the student. This was a common problem I encountered in my initial experiments with this workflow: an AI would be instructed not to reveal any information about the intended analysis, and then do something like name the dataset “logistic-regression-data.csv”.

While initial experimentation had the AI generate the datasets and the experimental design descriptions on the spot (and it did surprisingly well at this), we found that this had the potential for subtle errors. For example, one analysis examined generated data about patient recovery after different types of heart surgeries. In this scenario, the variable length_of_stay measured the number of days post-surgery the patient stayed at the hospital, and this variable was intended to be correlated to the type of surgery. When the data was generated, however, this correlation was not implemented, which lead to a difference between the intended analysis and the actual data. Since these sorts of errors are hidden in sets of data, they can be difficult to spot, and so we avoid this problem by pre-generating and testing experimental design descriptions and datasets to ensure accuracy.

Each pregenerated dataset comes with a chance of having a potential complication in the data that the student must account for. The current list of possible complications is violations of assumptions, underpowered true effects, aliased variables, outcome-dependent variables, post-treatment variables, confounding variables, and unbalanced groups. This is an intential design choice to force the student to diligently check their assumptions and variables. Currently, zero to one complications are chosen when generating each dataset, and these complications are checked to make sure they measurably distort the outcomes of the analysis if not correctly handled with the exception of underpowered true effects. For underpowered true effects, these complications are not meant to distort the analysis, but to impress on the student that even a correct analysis can miss true effects due to random chance in sampling or underpowered experiments.

Showcase

We provide an example showcase of what this learning experience might look like with a student. We show the uploaded materials for both stages, a transcript of the chat logs for both stages, and the two drafts of the student’s report.

Stage 1

This is an exercise in using an AI workflow to engage in statistical analysis of a pre-generated experiment and dataset. Your role will be to review the experimental design description and dataset, decide on the appropriate statistical tests to run, analyze the data using your statistical software of choice, and then write up a brief report presenting your statistical analysis. The goal is to give you a beginning-to-end experience of doing a statistical analysis. This exercise works in two stages, with two sets of folders marked stage 1 and stage 2. In stage 1, you will upload the content of the stage 1 folder (ai-orientation-1.md, data.csv, experimental-description.md) to your AI of choice. The AI’s role is to provide with assistance running the tests and writing the report. The AI should help with using the statistical software, enabling you to run your chosen tests, interpreting errors and outputs. The AI should not help you with making decisions about which methods are appropriate, analyzing the dataset, or hinting towards the correct answer.

For stage 1, you will upload the appropriate documents and then review experimental-description.md and data.csv. From the design description, you will choose the appropriate method to analyze the data. You will then decide on which variables, if any, should be excluded from the analysis for design reasons. You will then check that the relevant statistical assumptions are met for your chosen method, note any existing complications in the data, fit the model using your statistical software of choice, and then write the report. The report should include

  1. the design,
  2. your chosen method of analysis with justification,
  3. a decision to include or exclude for each variable with justification,
  4. checks of the relevant assumptions for your chosen method,
  5. results with effect sizes and confidence intervals, and
  6. interpretation of those results with respect to the initial experimental design.

Once the report is written, you should upload the report and the contents of the stage 2 folder (solution-key.md, experimental-description.md, data.csv, ai-orientation-2.md) to a new AI instance. This is to avoid prior discussion with the first AI instance from influencing the analysis of your report. Once the report is uploaded, the new AI instance will evaluate your report against the solution key. The AI will provide some hints as to errors in the analysis, if any exist, and then give you one opportunity to find and revise the errors. If revision is necessary, make the revisions and reupload the revised report. The AI will then reveal the contents of the solution key, included which variables should have been excluded, what complications existed in the data (if any), the results of the statistical tests and model fitting, and the intended interpretation of those results.

This project is expected to be completed in 20-60 minutes depending on your fluency with statistical analysis and your chosen statistical software. While you have access to the solution key in order to upload it to the AI in stage 2, you are strongly encouraged not to look at it before it is revealed at the end of the exercise.

You are an AI assistant helping a student learn to write a minimal statistical analysis. The goal is for a student to be presented with a short experimental design description and a dataset and then write up a complete statistical analysis on the dataset. This dataset may have complications included, such as violations of assumptions, underpowered true effects, aliased variables, outcome-dependent variables, post-treatment variables, confounding variables, and unbalanced groups, so the student will have to check for common complications to ensure their analysis is correct. Your role is to assist the student in this learning experiment without giving away hints to the true solution. Once the report is written, the student will move on to stage 2. For stage 2, the student will upload their report to a new, fresh AI instance, along with a pre-generated key and a new orientation document. This other AI instance will engage in a revision round with the student and then present the answer key, any included complications, and the true effects used to generate the data. The entire analysis is intended to be completed in a single sitting of approximately 20-60 minutes, depending on the student’s familiarity with their software of choice and the statistical analysis. The report should include

  1. the design,
  2. your chosen method of analysis with justification,
  3. a decision to include or exclude for each variable with justification,
  4. checks of the relevant assumptions for your chosen method,
  5. results with effect sizes and confidence intervals, and
  6. interpretation of those results with respect to the initial experimental design.

The student might be working on this independently or as part of a course on statistics. The student might be generally unfamiliar with their statistical software of choice or with statistics more broadly. Your role is to assist the student with syntax and functions, error messages and debugging, how to run a method that the student has chosen, and explaining what a piece of output means if asked. You should not choose the method, choose which variables to include or exclude, write the report’s prose or interpretation, or run the analysis for them.

You have not been given an answer key. This is an intentional design choice to prevent you from inadvertently providing this information to the student. At no point should you attempt to retype, regenerate, summarize, or analyze the dataset on your own. At no point should you attempt to provide a “right answer” or hint at potential complications in the data. Instead, you must work only from the student’s own code and output.

Once an initial draft of the report is complete, tell the student to upload the report, along with the orientation document and solution key in the stage two folder to a fresh instance of AI to move on to the next stage.

Surgical approach and recovery after colectomy

A surgical department randomized 200 adults scheduled for elective colectomy to either open surgery or laparoscopic surgery, 100 patients per approach. Before surgery, staff recorded each patient’s age, body mass index, and whether they had diabetes. The hospital’s records system also captured how many days each patient stayed in hospital after the operation.

Thirty days after surgery, patients completed the QoR-15, a quality-of-recovery questionnaire scored from 0 to 150, with higher scores meaning better recovery.

The department wants to know whether surgical approach affects quality of recovery at 30 days.

Variables

Variable Description When measured
patient_id Patient identifier
approach Surgical approach (Open, Laparoscopic) Randomization
age Age in years Before surgery
bmi Body mass index (kg/m²) Before surgery
diabetes Diabetes diagnosis (No, Yes) Before surgery
length_of_stay Days in hospital after surgery At discharge
qor15_30d QoR-15 score, 0 to 150 30 days after surgery

The data are in colectomy-data.csv.

NoteUser · turn 0

Alright, I’m wanting to do my analysis and write my report in RStudio as an R markdown file. I’ve used RStudio before and created similar reports, but it’s been a while, so I’ve forgotten a lot of the details on how to get everything set up.

Looking at the experiment description, it seems like our main dependent variable is going to be this QoR-15 score. This is continuous data, so we’re not really looking at contingency tables or logistic regression methods. Our main independent variable is going to be the surgical approach, which is categorical. We could simply do a t-test, but this would miss out on the other variables we have data for, so I think we’d be best served with an ANCOVA approach so we can adjust for things like age, BMI, and the like.

Okay, if that’s the direction I’d like to go, what do I need to do to get started? Any packages I need to include for this?

TipClaude · turn 1

Here’s how to get set up in RStudio.

1. Create the R Markdown file

  • File → New File → R Markdown…, give it a title, choose HTML (or PDF/Word) output, and click OK.
  • Save the .Rmd in the same folder as colectomy-data.csv. R Markdown knits relative to the file’s own folder, so read.csv("colectomy-data.csv") will work without a full path.
  • Delete the template content below the YAML header (the block between the --- lines).

2. Packages that are useful for an ANCOVA workflow

None of these are strictly required, since base R can fit the model with lm(). They make the work easier, though:

Package What it’s for
tidyverse Reading data (read_csv), wrangling (dplyr), plotting (ggplot2)
car Anova() for Type II/III sums of squares, leveneTest(), vif()
emmeans Adjusted (estimated marginal) means and contrasts with CIs
effectsize Effect sizes such as partial \eta^2
performance check_model(), a quick panel of assumption-check plots
knitr kable() for clean tables in the knitted report

Install them once from the console, not inside the Rmd:

install.packages(c("tidyverse", "car", "emmeans", "effectsize", "performance", "knitr"))

3. Setup chunk at the top of your Rmd

```{r setup, include=FALSE}
knitr::opts_chunk$set(echo = TRUE, message = FALSE, warning = FALSE)
library(tidyverse)
library(car)
library(emmeans)
library(effectsize)
library(performance)
library(knitr)
```

4. Read the data and set factor types

```{r load-data}
dat <- read_csv("colectomy-data.csv")
str(dat)
summary(dat)
```

read_csv will read approach and diabetes as character columns. You’ll want to convert them to factors with factor(). If you want a particular group as the reference level, you can set it with the levels = argument.

5. Outline your sections

It may help to add headers that mirror the required report sections: Design, Method & Justification, Variable Selection, Assumption Checks, Results, and Interpretation. That way you can fill them in as you go.

Which variables go into the model, and why, is your call to make and justify in the report. Once you’ve decided and written some code, paste your code or output here and I can help with syntax, errors, or reading the output.

NoteUser · turn 2

Okay, for packages, I also have dplyr, ggplot2, ggpubr installed. I don’t remember exactly what they do, but I think they might be useful here?

TipClaude · turn 3

They’re useful, and two of them you already have through the tidyverse:

  • dplyr is data wrangling: filter(), select(), mutate() (e.g., converting columns to factors), group_by() + summarise() for group descriptives. It’s loaded automatically by library(tidyverse).
  • ggplot2 is the plotting system: boxplots, scatterplots, histograms, Q-Q plots. It’s also part of the tidyverse, so it’s loaded automatically too.
  • ggpubr is not part of the tidyverse. It’s a wrapper around ggplot2 that makes publication-style plots quickly, with functions like ggboxplot(), ggscatter(), ggqqplot(), ggdensity(), and it can add p-values or regression lines to plots. It’s handy if you’d rather not build plots layer by layer.

So in your setup chunk, library(tidyverse) covers dplyr and ggplot2. Just add:

library(ggpubr)

A quick example of each style, so you can see the difference:

ggplot(dat, aes(x = approach, y = qor15_30d)) + geom_boxplot()

ggboxplot(dat, x = "approach", y = "qor15_30d")

Both give the same kind of plot, so use whichever feels more comfortable.

NoteUser · turn 4

Okay, I’m trying to remember what the process is for viewing the document as we go. Is it this knitting option? Or do I need to do something else?

TipClaude · turn 5

Yes, Knit is how you see the full rendered document, but there are a couple of ways to view things as you go.

1. Run chunks interactively (fastest while working)

  • Click the green ▶ arrow at the top-right of a chunk, or press Ctrl+Shift+Enter (Cmd+Shift+Enter on Mac), to run that chunk.
  • Ctrl+Enter runs just the current line or selection.
  • Output appears right under the chunk in the editor. If you’d rather see it in the Console and Plots pane, click the gear ⚙ next to Knit and choose “Chunk Output in Console.”
  • Objects you create this way show up in the Environment pane, so later chunks can use them.

2. Knit (the full rendered report)

  • Click Knit at the top of the editor, or press Ctrl+Shift+K.
  • This runs the whole document from scratch in a clean session and produces the HTML, PDF, or Word file, which opens in a viewer window or the Viewer pane.
  • To have it show in the Viewer pane instead of a popup, go to the gear ⚙ → “Preview in Viewer Pane.”

One gotcha: knitting does not use your Environment. If something works when you run chunks interactively but fails on knit, it’s usually because a package is loaded, or a variable is created, somewhere other than in the Rmd itself, or the chunks are out of order. Everything the report needs has to be in the file, top to bottom.

A good rhythm is to run chunks interactively while you’re building and knit every so often to make sure the whole thing still renders cleanly.

NoteUser · turn 6
---
title: "Colectomy Data Report"
output: html_document
date: "2026-11-12"
---

```{r setup, include=FALSE}
knitr::opts_chunk$set(echo = TRUE)
library(tidyverse)
library(car)
library(ggpubr)
library(emmeans)
library(effectsize)
library(performance)
library(knitr)
```

```{r load-data}
dat <- read_csv("colectomy-data.csv")
str(dat)
summary(dat)
```

## Experimental Design

## Analysis of Data

## Assumption for ANCOVA

## Fitting the Model

## Interpretation of the Model

Alright, here’s the file as is. We see the data summaries and then the section headers for later. I didn’t convert the approach and diabetes columns to factor, so I need to do that

TipClaude · turn 7

Good start. Here’s how to convert those two columns. You can put this right after read_csv() in your load-data chunk, or in its own chunk:

dat <- dat %>%
  mutate(
    approach = factor(approach),
    diabetes = factor(diabetes)
  )

str(dat)  # confirm they now show as Factor

By default, factor() orders levels alphabetically, so Laparoscopic will be the reference level for approach and No for diabetes. If you want a different reference group, set the order explicitly. The first level listed becomes the reference:

approach = factor(approach, levels = c("Open", "Laparoscopic"))

The reference level matters mainly for how you read the coefficients later. The approach coefficient will be “the other group minus the reference group,” so pick whichever direction you find most natural to interpret.

You can check the levels with:

levels(dat$approach)
table(dat$approach)

One small tip: if you run str(dat) and summary(dat) after the conversion, the summary will show counts per level for the factors instead of just “character,” which is more informative for your report.

NoteUser · turn 8

Alright, that’s done, and now I can see better summaries for those columns. I see that we have 100 subjects each for the two different approaches, which is good. There’s no funkiness with group sizes. Diabetes does have a size difference between yes and no, but that should still be okay with randomization.

Hmmm. Okay, now we need to start picking things apart. Our main factor is the approach, and our main outcome of interest is qor15. Age, BMI, and diabetes status are all measured prior to surgery. I’m not sure if any of those are correlated to how the approach is selected. Actually, the design description says it was randomized, so we expect no correlation there. Length of stay, however, is post-surgery and seems like it would generally correlate with quality of recovery. Longer stays seem like they would indicate more difficult recoveries, so we might want to exclude length of stay from our analysis?

TipClaude · turn 9

Those are your calls to make and justify, and it sounds like you’re thinking through the right questions: when each variable was measured relative to randomization, and how it might relate to treatment and outcome. Whatever you decide, write that reasoning into your Variable Selection section, since the timing argument is the kind of justification the report asks for.

I can’t tell you which variables to keep or drop, but here are tools to check the things you’re wondering about.

Pre-surgery covariates by group, to see what randomization gave you in this sample:

dat %>%
  group_by(approach) %>%
  summarise(
    n = n(),
    age_mean = mean(age), age_sd = sd(age),
    bmi_mean = mean(bmi), bmi_sd = sd(bmi),
    pct_diabetes = mean(diabetes == "Yes") * 100
  )

How variables relate to each other and to the outcome:

dat %>%
  select(age, bmi, length_of_stay, qor15_30d) %>%
  cor()

pairs(dat[, c("age", "bmi", "length_of_stay", "qor15_30d")])

ggboxplot(dat, x = "approach", y = "length_of_stay")

Categorical vs. categorical:

table(dat$approach, dat$diabetes)

These will show you associations in the data. Remember that an association alone doesn’t settle whether a variable belongs in the model; that comes back to the design reasoning you’re already doing. Run these and paste the output if you want help reading any of it.

NoteUser · turn 10

Hmmm. Can I paste those snippets into the console? Or do I need to run it as part of the report itself? I’d kinda like to keep the exploratory stuff out of the report until I’m more sure how I want to include it and write about it

TipClaude · turn 11

Yes, you can paste them straight into the console. Because you’ve already run your setup and load-data chunks interactively, dat (with the factor conversions) and your packages are in the Environment, so the console can see them.

A few other options, depending on how you like to work:

  • A scratch R script: File → New File → R Script. Paste the exploratory code there and run lines with Ctrl+Enter. It’s easier to edit and rerun than the console, and you can save it as something like explore.R without it touching the report.

  • A chunk that runs but doesn’t print: if you want it in the Rmd for later, add include=FALSE to the chunk header. It runs on knit but nothing appears in the output. Or use eval=FALSE to keep the code in the file without running it at all.

    ```{r explore, include=FALSE}
    # exploratory code here
    ```

The only catch with the console or a scratch script is that if you restart R or open a fresh session, you’ll need to rerun the setup and load-data chunks first so dat exists again.

NoteUser · turn 12
> dat %>%
+     group_by(approach) %>%
+     summarise(
+         n = n(),
+         age_mean = mean(age), age_sd = sd(age),
+         bmi_mean = mean(bmi), bmi_sd = sd(bmi),
+         pct_diabetes = mean(diabetes == "Yes") * 100
+     )

Error in dat %>% group_by(approach) %>% summarise(n = n(), age_mean = mean(age),  :
  could not find function "%>%"

I get an error with a copy paste here

TipClaude · turn 13

That error means the tidyverse isn’t loaded in your current session. %>% (the pipe) comes from the tidyverse, via the magrittr package, so R doesn’t recognize it until the library is loaded.

To fix it, run your setup chunk (click its green ▶ arrow), or just run this in the console:

library(tidyverse)

Then paste the snippet again. If dat also turns out to be missing (an “object ‘dat’ not found” error), run your load-data chunk too.

This usually happens after a restart or when opening the project fresh. Your Environment pane is a good quick check: if dat isn’t listed there, the chunks haven’t been run in this session.

Alternatively, R 4.1 and later has a built-in pipe, |>, that works without loading any packages. But you’ll still need the tidyverse loaded for group_by() and summarise(), so loading it is the real fix.

NoteUser · turn 14

Oh, it doesn’t automatically find dat either

TipClaude · turn 15

Right. Same cause: the console session is fresh, so nothing from your Rmd exists there yet. Run your chunks in order:

  1. The setup chunk (loads the packages)
  2. The load-data chunk (creates dat and converts the factors)

A shortcut: put your cursor in the load-data chunk and press Ctrl+Alt+P (Cmd+Option+P on Mac). That runs all chunks above the current one. You can also use the Run dropdown at the top of the editor → “Run All Chunks Above.” Then run load-data itself.

After that, dat should appear in the Environment pane, and your exploratory snippets will work in the console.

If read_csv() gives a “file not found” error when you run it interactively, check the console’s working directory with getwd(). Knitting uses the Rmd’s own folder, but the console might be somewhere else. You can fix that with Session → Set Working Directory → To Source File Location.

NoteUser · turn 16

Ohhhh, Okay, I think I have it now.

  approach         n age_mean age_sd bmi_mean bmi_sd pct_diabetes
  <fct>        <int>    <dbl>  <dbl>    <dbl>  <dbl>        <dbl>
1 Laparoscopic   100     61.7   9.50     29.6   4.45           24
2 Open           100     64.0   9.66     28.8   5.02           20

Seems like things have been divided up fairly evenly.

                        age          bmi length_of_stay  qor15_30d
age             1.000000000  0.001317418     0.11832338 -0.3193283
bmi             0.001317418  1.000000000    -0.05794214 -0.1225380
length_of_stay  0.118323378 -0.057942139     1.00000000 -0.5670716
qor15_30d      -0.319328294 -0.122538005    -0.56707157  1.0000000

LoS seems like it has a fairly strong correlation with QoR? Which is as we expect, they’re kinda measuring the same thing.

pasted the scatterplots (I really love that I can just copy paste images right into here from RStudio. How handy!) We do definitely see some correlation in the LoS and QoR scatterplots.

WarningImage placeholder

Scatterplot matrix (pairs()) of age, BMI, length of stay and QoR-15.

I did different boxplots for length of stay that you suggested and also with QoR. Again, feels like we’re getting the same effects. Open surgery appears to lead to longer stays and worse QoR scores.

WarningImage placeholder

Boxplots of length of stay by approach, and QoR-15 by approach.

So, since LoS and QoR are kinda measuring the same thing, we should exclude LoS. From the boxplots, we can kinda see what would happen if we didn’t. We’d try to adjust for LoS, but that would end up hiding some of the effect on QoR as well. The justification for this, though, is just the measuring the same thing aspect, though.

TipClaude · turn 17

Glad it’s working, and yes, pasting plots straight in is handy.

Your reading of the output is accurate:

  • Group summaries: the means, SDs, and diabetes percentages are similar across the two arms, with small differences (about 2 years in mean age, under 1 unit of BMI, 4 percentage points in diabetes).
  • Correlation matrix: length of stay has the largest correlation with QoR-15 (r \approx -0.57), followed by age (r \approx -0.32), with BMI weaker (r \approx -0.12). The covariates are only weakly correlated with each other.
  • Boxplots: the Open group has a higher median length of stay and a lower median QoR-15 than the Laparoscopic group.

Whether to include or exclude length of stay, and why, is your decision, so I’ll leave the reasoning to you. You’ve noticed that your justification feels thinner than your conclusion. That’s worth sitting with before you write that section, since the report asks for a justification for each variable, and you’ll want one you’re confident defending. Your design description and variable table are good places to anchor it.

When you’re ready to write it up, these outputs belong in the report. The group summary table fits your design or variable-selection section; kable() will make it look clean:

dat %>%
  group_by(approach) %>%
  summarise(...) %>%   # your same summarise() call
  kable(digits = 1)

The same pattern works for the correlation matrix: kable(cor(...), digits = 2).

NoteUser · turn 18

Okay, moving on to assumptions. Let me see if I remember the assumptions we need for ANCOVA. I know we need independent observations. This should be met from the experimental design. We don’t really expect one person’s recovery to impact another person’s surgical recovery.

We need our data to be linear on the covariates. I’ll have to check that. We need equal slopes. I’m not sure if I remember how to check that. We do interaction terms for that, yes?

Normality of residuals, we’ll have to check that. I’m not sure I remember exactly how to do that either. Equal variance, I think we might have already seen that they’re roughly equal in the data table up above, but we’ll want to test that and make sure as well. Anything I’m missing?

TipClaude · turn 19

Your list covers the core assumptions. A few additions and one clarification:

Your list:

  1. Independence of observations, which you argue from the design.
  2. Linearity between each continuous covariate and the outcome.
  3. Homogeneity of regression slopes: yes, you test this with interaction terms.
  4. Normality of residuals.
  5. Homogeneity of variance, which concerns the variance of the outcome residuals across groups. The table you made shows SDs of age and BMI, which are covariates, so it doesn’t speak to this assumption. You’ll still want to check it separately.

Commonly added:

  1. Covariates independent of the treatment. Often argued from randomization, and you can point to your balance table.
  2. Outliers and influential points, which aren’t strictly an assumption but are part of a standard check.
  3. Multicollinearity among predictors, if you have several covariates. vif() from car checks this.

How to check each one in R. Replace the right-hand side with whatever model you choose:

fit <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + covariate1 + covariate2, data = dat)

fit_int <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach * covariate1 + approach * covariate2, data = dat)
Anova(fit_int, type = 3)        # look at the interaction rows
anova(fit, fit_int)

ggscatter(dat, x = "covariate1", y = "qor15_30d", color = "approach",
          add = "reg.line")

res <- residuals(fit)
ggqqplot(res)
shapiro.test(res)

leveneTest(res ~ approach, data = dat)

vif(fit)

check_model(fit)

For the slopes check, a non-significant interaction is consistent with equal slopes. For Levene’s test and Shapiro-Wilk, a non-significant p-value means no evidence of a violation. With n = 200, Shapiro-Wilk can flag trivial departures, so many people lean on the Q-Q plot as the primary evidence.

NoteUser · turn 20

Actually, going on a tiny bit of a tangent here, but covariates being independent from treatment, how is that actually handled irl? I mean, we can certainly point to our balance table in this case and say that the covariates have been divided up equally, but that feels a little weird. The covariates being independent from the treatment is given by the randomization, but we can still theoretically randomize the treatment and get highly unequal balance. How is that handled? It feels hacky if we were to say “Oh, we looked at the balance table and didn’t like the distribution, so we rerandomized”. Do you just bite the bullet and say “we had unequal balance, but that’s due to random chance in the randomization process, so we continue on regardless”

TipClaude · turn 21

Your instinct is right on both counts, and this is a well-studied question.

What randomization actually guarantees

Randomization makes covariates independent of treatment in expectation, over all possible randomizations. Any single realized allocation can be imbalanced by chance. The key point is that this chance imbalance is already accounted for in the inference: p-values and confidence intervals are calibrated over the randomization distribution, which includes the unlucky allocations. So “we had some imbalance by chance, and we proceed” is the textbook-correct stance, not biting a bullet.

Why significance-testing balance is discouraged

Many trials used to report p-values comparing baseline characteristics between arms. CONSORT and most methodologists now advise against this. If randomization was done properly, the null hypothesis is true by construction, so any “significant” difference is by definition a false positive. A descriptive table (means, SDs, percentages) is the recommended way to report balance. Then you judge whether any difference is large enough to matter clinically, not statistically.

How imbalance is handled in practice

  • Pre-specified covariate adjustment. This is the main tool, and it’s what ANCOVA does. Adjusting for prognostic baseline covariates corrects for chance imbalance in them and usually tightens the confidence interval. The important part is choosing covariates in advance, based on prior knowledge of what predicts the outcome, not after looking at which ones came out imbalanced. Choosing adjustment variables based on observed imbalance opens the door to analytic flexibility.
  • Design-stage fixes, done before allocation:
    • Stratified (blocked) randomization: randomize separately within strata, e.g., diabetic and non-diabetic patients, so those groups are balanced by design.
    • Minimization: each new patient is allocated, partly at random, to whichever arm best preserves balance across several factors. It’s common in smaller trials.
    • Rerandomization: your “hacky” idea is actually a legitimate method (Morgan & Rubin, 2012), if the acceptance rule is specified in advance (e.g., “redraw until the Mahalanobis distance between arms is below threshold a”), and the analysis accounts for the restricted set of allowable allocations. What’s hacky is doing it ad hoc and then analyzing as if it were simple randomization.

Summary: randomize once (or with a pre-specified restriction), report balance descriptively, adjust for pre-specified prognostic covariates, and don’t let the observed balance drive the analysis choices.

NoteUser · turn 22

Oh, how do I do a numbered list in RMarkdown?

TipClaude · turn 23

Same as regular Markdown: start each line with a number and a period, with a blank line before the list.

Some text before the list.

1. First item
2. Second item
3. Third item

A few details:

  • The numbers don’t have to be correct. Markdown renumbers automatically, so 1. 1. 1. still renders as 1, 2, 3. That makes reordering easy.

  • Blank line before the list: if the list comes right after a paragraph with no blank line, it may render as plain text instead of a list. This is the most common gotcha.

  • Nested items: indent by 4 spaces (or a tab).

    1. Independence
    2. Linearity
        - checked with scatterplots
        - by group
    3. Equal slopes
  • Bullets work the same way with - or * instead of numbers.

NoteUser · turn 24

Okay, what do I need to do to insert the code into the markdown file and have it’s output shown? for the balance table

TipClaude · turn 25

You put code in a code chunk. Anything inside a chunk runs when you knit, and its output (tables, plots, printed results) appears right below it in the report.

To insert a chunk:

  • Press Ctrl+Alt+I (Cmd+Option+I on Mac), or
  • Click the green +C button at the top of the editor → R, or
  • Type it by hand: three backticks plus {r}, your code, then three backticks to close.

Your balance table as a chunk:

```{r balance-table}
dat %>%
  group_by(approach) %>%
  summarise(
    n = n(),
    age_mean = mean(age), age_sd = sd(age),
    bmi_mean = mean(bmi), bmi_sd = sd(bmi),
    pct_diabetes = mean(diabetes == "Yes") * 100
  ) %>%
  kable(digits = 1, caption = "Baseline characteristics by surgical approach")
```

Put it under whichever section header you want it in, with your prose above or below it as normal text outside the chunk.

Controlling what shows up, set in the chunk header:

Option Effect
(none) Code and output shown, the default from your setup chunk
echo=FALSE Output only, code hidden
include=FALSE Runs but shows nothing
eval=FALSE Code shown but not run

For example, {r balance-table, echo=FALSE} gives you just the table. That’s nice in a report, but whether your instructor wants the code visible is worth checking.

The chunk label (balance-table) is optional, but each label must be unique within the document, or knitting will fail.

NoteUser · turn 26
WarningImage placeholder

Linearity scatterplots: QoR-15 against age, against BMI, and by diabetes status, coloured by approach.

I’m not really sure how to interpret this for linearity. I mean, it’s not super highly linear, but it’s also not obviously nonlinear. It’s just kinda a big mess? Are big messes linear?

TipClaude · turn 27

Big messes can be linear. Linearity is about the shape of the average relationship, not how tightly the points cluster around it.

  • Scatter (noise) is about the strength of the relationship. A lot of spread just means the covariate explains a modest share of the variation, which is fine for ANCOVA.
  • Linearity asks whether the trend through the cloud is a straight line or something curved, like a U-shape, a plateau, or a bend. A violation looks like points systematically above the line at both ends and below it in the middle, or similar.

So the question to ask of a plot is: is there any curvature in the middle of the cloud that a straight line misses? not are the points close to the line?

Two things that make this easier to judge

  1. Add a smoother. A loess curve follows the data without forcing a straight line. If it roughly tracks the straight line, linearity is reasonable; if it bends clearly, that’s a concern.

    ggplot(dat, aes(x = age, y = qor15_30d, color = approach)) +
      geom_point(alpha = 0.6) +
      geom_smooth(method = "lm", se = FALSE) +
      geom_smooth(method = "loess", se = FALSE, linetype = "dashed")
  2. Check the residuals from the fitted model, which is often clearer than raw scatterplots:

    crPlots(fit)                  # component + residual plots (car), one per covariate
    plot(fit, which = 1)          # residuals vs fitted; look for a curve in the red line

    In crPlots, the dashed line is the linear fit and the solid line is a smoother. Ideally they roughly overlap.

About diabetes: linearity only applies to continuous covariates. Diabetes is a two-level factor, so the model just estimates a shift between No and Yes, and there’s no “shape” to check. That third plot is better read as a look at how the outcome distributions differ by diabetes status and approach. For a categorical covariate, the relevant check is the interaction (equal-slopes) test, approach * diabetes.

NoteUser · turn 28
WarningImage placeholder

Age and BMI scatterplots with linear fits and dashed loess curves, by approach.

Okay, I think these might be reasonably linear? I don’t like the swoop of the red line on the left hand side of the first image, but I think that might just be overthinking a relatively messy spread on the data?

TipClaude · turn 29

That’s a reasonable thing to wonder about, and there’s a known reason loess curves misbehave at the edges.

Why the ends of a loess curve are unreliable

  • Few points: at the extremes of the x-axis there’s little data, so the smoother is fitting just a handful of points. A few high or low observations can pull it sharply.
  • One-sided neighborhoods: in the middle, loess averages points on both sides of each x value. At the edges it only has points on one side, which makes it more prone to swooping.

The red curve’s swoop on the left is driven by roughly the youngest 4 or 5 Laparoscopic patients. Wiggles in sparse regions are usually given much less weight than a consistent bend through the bulk of the data.

Two ways to make the judgment less eyeball-dependent

  1. Show the uncertainty band. If the straight line sits inside the loess band, the curve isn’t distinguishable from linear:

    ggplot(dat, aes(x = age, y = qor15_30d, color = approach)) +
      geom_point(alpha = 0.6) +
      geom_smooth(method = "lm", se = FALSE) +
      geom_smooth(method = "loess", se = TRUE, linetype = "dashed")
  2. A formal check: add a squared term and see if it contributes anything. For a centered quadratic in age:

    fit_quad <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + I((age - mean(age))^2) + ..., data = dat)
    anova(fit, fit_quad)

    Replace ... with the rest of your chosen model. A non-significant result means no evidence that curvature improves the fit.

Whether you conclude linearity is adequate is your call. Either way, in the report you can describe what you saw (“the loess curve deviates at low ages, where few observations are present”) and what you did about it. Showing that you noticed and checked is the kind of thing that makes an assumptions section convincing.

NoteUser · turn 30

For the fit, do I need to add diabetes? qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes? Or is that only for continuous covariates?

TipClaude · turn 31

You can include it. lm() handles factor covariates fine, and an ANCOVA model can mix continuous and categorical covariates. Whether diabetes should be in the model is your variable-selection decision. The linearity rule doesn’t settle it either way, since linearity only concerns how continuous covariates enter the model, not which covariates you include.

Mechanically, here’s what happens if you include it:

fit <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes, data = dat)

R automatically creates an indicator for the non-reference level, so the coefficient diabetesYes is the adjusted difference in mean QoR-15 for patients with diabetes vs. without, holding the other terms constant.

For the quadratic linearity check, you’d add the squared term only for the continuous covariate you’re testing. Diabetes stays in as-is:

fit_quad <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + I((age - mean(age))^2) + bmi + diabetes,
               data = dat)
anova(fit, fit_quad)

You can’t square a two-level factor, and there’s no curvature to test. The same applies to the other assumption checks: diabetes goes into the equal-slopes test (approach * diabetes), but not into linearity.

The important thing is that fit and fit_quad contain the same terms apart from the squared one, so that anova() is comparing like with like.

NoteUser · turn 32

Okay, yeah. I do want to include diabetes, I just couldn’t remember the details of the lm model. Right now, I’m only focused on the ancova fit. I don’t see enough reason in the scatterplots to feel the need to investigate nonlinearity further.

TipClaude · turn 33

That works. Recording what you looked at and why you’re satisfied is a perfectly good basis for the assumptions section.

Here’s the toolkit for the ANCOVA fit itself, using your model:

fit <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes, data = dat)

ANCOVA table:

Anova(fit, type = 2)

Type II tests each term adjusted for the others (without interactions), which is the usual choice for an additive ANCOVA. If you include interaction terms elsewhere, such as in your equal-slopes check, Type III is what’s typically used for that model.

Coefficients with confidence intervals:

summary(fit)
confint(fit)

The approachOpen row (or approachLaparoscopic, depending on your reference level) is the adjusted mean difference between approaches.

Adjusted means per group, and their difference with a CI:

emm <- emmeans(fit, ~ approach)
emm                        # adjusted mean for each approach
pairs(emm)                 # difference between approaches
confint(pairs(emm))        # with a 95% CI

Effect size:

eta_squared(fit, partial = TRUE)

Then you can run the assumption checks on this same fit: equal slopes, check_model(), ggqqplot(residuals(fit)), leveneTest(residuals(fit) ~ approach, data = dat), and vif().

When you have output, paste it here if you want help reading any of it.

NoteUser · turn 34
Anova Table (Type III tests)

Response: qor15_30d
                   Sum Sq  Df  F value    Pr(>F)
(Intercept)       26665.9   1 183.9194 < 2.2e-16 ***
approach            171.2   1   1.1811 0.2785037
age                1654.2   1  11.4092 0.0008848 ***
bmi                 464.9   1   3.2062 0.0749351 .
diabetes            961.1   1   6.6291 0.0107854 *
approach:age         12.7   1   0.0875 0.7677488
approach:bmi         65.6   1   0.4526 0.5019198
approach:diabetes    18.4   1   0.1272 0.7217516
Residuals         27837.4 192
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
Analysis of Variance Table

Model 1: qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi
Model 2: qor15_30d ~ approach * age + approach * bmi + approach * diabetes
  Res.Df   RSS Df Sum of Sq      F   Pr(>F)
1    196 30084
2    192 27837  4    2246.2 3.8731 0.004752 **
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1

    Shapiro-Wilk normality test

data:  res
W = 0.99455, p-value = 0.6834

Levene's Test for Homogeneity of Variance (center = median)
       Df F value  Pr(>F)
group   1  4.4228 0.03672 *
      198
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
approach      age      bmi
1.020890 1.014430 1.006488

Alright, time to roll up my sleeves. For the interaction terms, we’re miles above 0.05 for each of them, so we interpret that as no evidence for unequal slopes. For normality, we’re way above 0.05 there as well, so we have no problems there. Homogeneity of variance though is a little fiddly. Our null there is that the variances are equal. However, we have evidence to reject the null, since our p-value is less than 0.05. That might be a complication in the data set. Do I remember what to do about unequal variance? Is there an option to weight the groups to account for that?

TipClaude · turn 35

Your readings of the interaction rows and the Shapiro-Wilk test are right. Before going further, though, there’s a code issue to fix, because it affects several of these results.

Your fit doesn’t include diabetes

Look at Model 1 in the comparison:

Model 1: qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi

The vif() output also lists only approach, age, bmi. So the fit object currently in your session was fitted without diabetes, probably from an earlier run before you added it. That has two consequences:

  1. The anova(fit, fit_int) comparison is invalid as an equal-slopes test. It’s testing 4 extra terms at once (the diabetes main effect plus the three interactions), so the significant p = 0.0048 can’t be read as evidence of unequal slopes. For a clean comparison, the two models should differ only in the interaction terms.
  2. The Shapiro-Wilk, Levene, and VIF results came from the model without diabetes. res was computed from that fit.

The fix is to refit and rerun everything downstream:

fit <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes, data = dat)
fit_int <- lm(qor15_30d ~ approach * age + approach * bmi + approach * diabetes, data = dat)

anova(fit, fit_int)            # now a 3-df test of just the interactions
res <- residuals(fit)
shapiro.test(res)
leveneTest(res ~ approach, data = dat)
vif(fit)

The Type III table with the interaction rows is fine as it is, since that came from fit_int, which already includes diabetes. The re-run results may change, including Levene’s.

If unequal variance holds up after refitting

You’re right that weighting is an option. The common approaches are:

1. Heteroskedasticity-consistent (robust) standard errors. Keep the same coefficients but compute standard errors that don’t assume equal variance. car can do this with what you already have loaded:

Anova(fit, type = 2, white.adjust = "hc3")

emm_rob <- emmeans(fit, ~ approach, vcov. = hccm(fit, type = "hc3"))
confint(pairs(emm_rob))

2. Weighted least squares / group-specific variances. Model a separate residual variance for each approach using gls() from nlme, which ships with R:

library(nlme)
fit_gls <- gls(qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes,
               weights = varIdent(form = ~ 1 | approach),
               data = dat)
summary(fit_gls)
intervals(fit_gls)
anova(fit, fit_gls)  # won't work directly, since lm vs gls; refit the lm version with gls() to compare

emmeans() also works on gls objects.

Some context for choosing. OLS is fairly robust to unequal variances when the group sizes are equal, as yours are (100/100). The danger is greatest when the smaller group has the larger variance. Many people still report robust SEs as a sensitivity check. It can also help to look at the size of the difference, not just the p-value:

dat %>% mutate(res = res) %>% group_by(approach) %>% summarise(sd_res = sd(res))

A ratio of residual SDs near 1 versus near 2 tells you more than whether p < 0.05, especially with n = 200, where small differences can reach significance.

Which approach to use, if any, is your call. Whatever you choose, state it and the reason in the assumptions section.

NoteUser · turn 36
Anova Table (Type III tests)

Response: qor15_30d
                   Sum Sq  Df  F value    Pr(>F)
(Intercept)       26665.9   1 183.9194 < 2.2e-16 ***
approach            171.2   1   1.1811 0.2785037
age                1654.2   1  11.4092 0.0008848 ***
bmi                 464.9   1   3.2062 0.0749351 .
diabetes            961.1   1   6.6291 0.0107854 *
approach:age         12.7   1   0.0875 0.7677488
approach:bmi         65.6   1   0.4526 0.5019198
approach:diabetes    18.4   1   0.1272 0.7217516
Residuals         27837.4 192
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
Analysis of Variance Table

Model 1: qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes
Model 2: qor15_30d ~ approach * age + approach * bmi + approach * diabetes
  Res.Df   RSS Df Sum of Sq      F Pr(>F)
1    195 27931
2    192 27837  3     93.11 0.2141 0.8866

    Shapiro-Wilk normality test

data:  res
W = 0.99684, p-value = 0.9582

Levene's Test for Homogeneity of Variance (center = median)
       Df F value  Pr(>F)
group   1  6.0145 0.01505 *
      198
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
approach      age      bmi diabetes
1.022815 1.014476 1.011044 1.006929

Okay, reran with diabetes included. Thanks for the catch. We do see that this makes the variances more detectably unequal, so no easy fix there. We might continue with OLS with the equal group sizes as the justification. I’m not sure if the increased significance of the Levene’s test should push us away from that option, but I think we can tentatively forge ahead for now

TipClaude · turn 37

The corrected outputs read cleanly now:

  • Equal slopes: the 3-df comparison gives F = 0.21, p = 0.89, which agrees with the individual interaction rows. Now that the models differ only by the interactions, that’s a valid test.
  • Normality: Shapiro-Wilk p = 0.96.
  • Multicollinearity: all VIFs are about 1.0, which is essentially no collinearity. You can note that alongside your other checks.
  • Variance: Levene’s p = 0.015.

On whether the smaller Levene’s p-value should change your mind: a p-value tells you how confident you can be that some difference exists, not how large it is. With 100 per group, a modest variance difference can reach significance. That’s why it’s worth getting the effect-size version before deciding how much weight to give this:

dat %>%
  mutate(res = residuals(fit)) %>%
  group_by(approach) %>%
  summarise(sd_res = sd(res), var_res = var(res))

That gives you a concrete ratio to cite in the report, e.g., “the residual SD was X in one group and Y in the other,” which makes the “equal group sizes make OLS robust” argument much more convincing than the p-value alone.

If you want extra support for forging ahead with OLS, a common approach is to report the robust-SE version as a sensitivity analysis: fit with OLS as your primary analysis, then show that the conclusion about approach doesn’t change with HC3 standard errors.

Anova(fit, type = 2, white.adjust = "hc3")
confint(pairs(emmeans(fit, ~ approach, vcov. = hccm(fit, type = "hc3"))))

If the two versions agree, that’s a strong one-sentence addition to your assumptions section. If they disagree, that’s important to know too. Whether to include it is up to you.

NoteUser · turn 38
  approach     sd_res var_res
  <fct>         <dbl>   <dbl>
1 Laparoscopic   13.2    175.
2 Open           10.4    108.

Hmmmm. I’m not sure about that var_res difference. That feels large?

TipClaude · turn 39

Variances are on a squared scale, which makes differences look bigger than they are. It helps to put it as a ratio:

\frac{s^2_{\text{Lap}}}{s^2_{\text{Open}}} = \frac{175}{108} \approx 1.62, \qquad \frac{s_{\text{Lap}}}{s_{\text{Open}}} = \frac{13.2}{10.4} \approx 1.27

So the Laparoscopic group’s residual SD is about 27% larger, or its variance about 1.6 times larger.

Rules of thumb you’ll see cited:

  • A largest-to-smallest variance ratio under about 2 is commonly treated as minor; some sources tolerate up to about 3 or 4 when group sizes are equal.
  • The robustness of OLS to unequal variances depends heavily on group sizes. With equal n, Type I error stays close to nominal even at fairly large ratios. The real trouble arises when the groups are unbalanced, especially when the smaller group has the larger variance.

These are heuristics, not hard cutoffs, and different textbooks draw the lines in different places. Whether 1.6 with 100/100 is acceptable is your judgment to state and defend. Citing the ratio and the balanced design together makes for a concrete argument.

If you want something firmer than a rule of thumb, that’s what the HC3 sensitivity check is for. It directly shows whether the unequal variance changes your inference about approach in this dataset.

NoteUser · turn 40
WarningImage placeholder

Q-Q plot of model residuals (ggqqplot(res)) with confidence band.

Oh, for vif, I’m assuming this is the chart that expresses that test? The points fitting the line like this is good?

TipClaude · turn 41

Not quite. This is a Q-Q plot, which checks normality of residuals, not multicollinearity. It’s the plot from ggqqplot(res). VIF doesn’t have a plot; it’s just the numbers you already got (all about 1.0).

Reading the Q-Q plot:

  • Each point is one residual. The x-axis shows where it would fall if the residuals were perfectly normal (theoretical quantiles), and the y-axis shows where it actually falls.
  • If the residuals are normal, the points lie along the straight line.
  • The grey band is a confidence envelope. Points within it are consistent with normality.

So yes, points following the line and staying inside the band is what you want to see. Things that would indicate a problem:

Pattern Suggests
Ends curve away in opposite directions (S-shape) Heavy or light tails
Both ends bend the same way (banana shape) Skewness
A few isolated points far off at the ends Outliers

Here the points track the line closely, with a slight wave in the middle that stays well within the band. That agrees with your Shapiro-Wilk result (p = 0.96). This plot plus that test makes a good pairing for the normality part of your assumptions section.

For VIF in the report: the usual interpretation is that values near 1 indicate essentially no collinearity, and concern typically starts around 5 or 10. Your values are all about 1.01 to 1.02. A small table works well:

kable(vif(fit), col.names = "VIF", digits = 2)
NoteUser · turn 42
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
approach      age      bmi diabetes
1.022815 1.014476 1.011044 1.006929

Oh, this was the vif stuff. I see. It wasn’t labeled in the output, so I missed it. I see, no worries.

TipClaude · turn 43

Right, that last block is the vif() output. vif() just prints a named vector with no header, so it’s easy to miss among other output. (The “Signif. codes” line above it belongs to the Levene’s test output.)

To make outputs easier to tell apart when running several checks in a row, you can label them:

cat("\n--- VIF ---\n")
vif(fit)

In the knitted report this mostly takes care of itself, since each check will sit under its own heading or chunk with your prose around it.

NoteUser · turn 44

Alright, for evaluating the ANCOVA, do I just use Anova(fit, type=3) again? Do I need to use a different type?

TipClaude · turn 45

For your final model, fit (no interaction terms), either type works. Type II and Type III give identical tests for every term when there are no interactions. The only visible difference is that Type III also prints an (Intercept) row, which you can ignore.

Anova(fit, type = 2)

Type II is the conventional choice for an additive ANCOVA, but if you report Type III, the results will be the same.

Background on the types:

Type What it tests When it matters
I (sequential), base anova() Each term adjusted only for terms listed before it Results depend on the order of terms in the formula, so it’s usually not what you want for ANCOVA
II Each term adjusted for all other terms, but not interactions involving it Standard for models without interactions
III Each term adjusted for everything, including interactions Used when interactions are in the model; main effects then also depend on contrast coding

So the main thing to avoid is base R’s lowercase anova(fit) for the ANCOVA table, since it’s sequential. Lowercase anova(fit, fit_int) for comparing two models, as you did for equal slopes, is fine.

The ANCOVA table gives you the test for approach. For the report’s effect sizes and confidence intervals, pair it with:

confint(pairs(emmeans(fit, ~ approach)))   # adjusted mean difference + 95% CI
eta_squared(fit, partial = TRUE)           # partial eta-squared
NoteUser · turn 46
Anova Table (Type II tests)

Response: qor15_30d
           Sum Sq  Df F value    Pr(>F)
approach   2141.0   1 14.9474 0.0001505 ***
age        2999.8   1 20.9432 8.409e-06 ***
bmi         555.5   1  3.8781 0.0503362 .
diabetes   2153.1   1 15.0318 0.0001444 ***
Residuals 27930.6 195
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
 contrast            estimate   SE  df lower.CL upper.CL
 Laparoscopic - Open     6.62 1.71 195     3.24     9.99

Results are averaged over the levels of: diabetes
Confidence level used: 0.95
Parameter | Eta2 (partial) |       95% CI
-----------------------------------------
approach  |           0.08 | [0.03, 1.00]
age       |           0.10 | [0.04, 1.00]
bmi       |           0.02 | [0.00, 1.00]
diabetes  |           0.07 | [0.02, 1.00]

- One-sided CIs: upper bound fixed at [1.00].

Okay, what are we looking at here? We see significant p-values for approach, age, and diabetes, and non-significance for bmi (albeit, it’s close. Maybe that’s something to investigate further with a little more power). In any case, we’re comfortable saying that approach, age, and diabetes do have an effect on qor. I also feel like I want to be seeing the various slopes in the anova results, but maybe that’s a different type?

For effect sizes, we get an estimated 6.62 difference in qor score between lap and open approaches. Could be as low as 3.24 or as high as 9.99 from the 95% confidence interval. Either way, we’re confident there is a difference. The difference seems kinda small out of a 150 point scale. Minor to moderate?

For the partial eta squares, that’s the proportion of variance attributable to that variable over the variance in the model not attributable to anything else? Is that how that’s phrased?

TipClaude · turn 47

You’re reading most of this correctly. Here’s each piece, plus one code issue.

The ANCOVA table

Each row tests whether that term explains variation in QoR-15 after adjusting for the other terms.

  • Approach: F(1, 195) = 14.95, p = 0.00015. This is the row that answers the study question.
  • Covariates: age and diabetes are significant; BMI is at p = 0.050, just above 0.05.

One distinction worth thinking about as you write: approach was randomized, while age, BMI, and diabetes were observed. The covariate rows are tests of adjusted associations with QoR-15, which you may want to phrase differently from the treatment effect. How you phrase it is up to you.

Where the slopes are

The Anova table only gives sums of squares and tests, not the estimates. The slopes and differences are in the coefficient table:

summary(fit)    # estimates, SEs, t-tests
confint(fit)    # 95% CIs for each coefficient

There you’ll see, for example, the change in QoR-15 per year of age, holding other terms constant. The approach coefficient there should match the 6.62 from emmeans (possibly with the opposite sign, depending on your reference level).

The adjusted difference

Your reading is right: the adjusted mean QoR-15 was 6.62 points higher for Laparoscopic than Open, with a 95% CI of 3.24 to 9.99. The CI excludes 0, which matches the significant F-test.

The note “Results are averaged over the levels of: diabetes” means the adjusted means are computed with continuous covariates at their means and averaged across diabetes levels, so it’s a covariate-adjusted comparison.

Whether that difference is small or meaningful is an interpretation call for you. One useful anchor: many instruments, including the QoR-15, have a published minimal clinically important difference (MCID). Comparing your estimate and CI against an MCID from the literature is a standard way to judge practical significance, rather than eyeballing it against the 0–150 range.

Partial eta-squared: a code fix and a definition

The fix: notice the header says “Type I”. eta_squared() on an lm object uses sequential sums of squares by default, so those values don’t match your Type II table. Pass it the Type II table instead:

eta_squared(Anova(fit, type = 2), partial = TRUE, alternative = "two.sided")

alternative = "two.sided" also gives a regular two-sided CI. The default one-sided CI with the upper bound fixed at 1.00 is why every row showed 1.00.

The definition: your phrasing is close. Precisely,

\eta^2_p = \frac{SS_{\text{effect}}}{SS_{\text{effect}} + SS_{\text{residual}}}

In words, it’s the proportion of variance attributable to that term, out of the variance not explained by the other terms in the model. For approach, about 7% of the variance remaining after age, BMI, and diabetes is attributable to approach.

You can verify it by hand from your table: 2141.0 / (2141.0 + 27930.6) \approx 0.071.

Stage 2

In stage 2, no substantive errors were found, so the only revision was to include relatively minor tweaks and typo fixes.

You are an AI assistant helping a student learn to write a minimal statistical analysis. The goal is for a student to be presented with a short experimental design description and a dataset and then write up a complete statistical analysis on the dataset. This learning experience is meant to be completed in two stages with two different AI assistants. You are the AI assistant for stage 2. In stage 1, the student received an pre-generated experimental design description and dataset. The student then had to decide on an appropriate method of analyzing the data, decide which variables should be included or excluded, test the various assumptions required by that method on the data, fit the model using their chosen statistical software, interpret the results, and then write a brief report. The student’s report should include

  1. the design,
  2. the student’s chosen method of analysis with justification,
  3. the student’s decision to include or exclude for each variable with justification,
  4. checks of the relevant assumptions for the student’s chosen method,
  5. results with effect sizes and confidence intervals, and
  6. interpretation of those results with respect to the initial experimental design.

Once the report is written, stage 1 is complete. The student will then move on to stage 2. The student will upload their report, the experimental design description, the dataset, and the review key to you, along with this document. Your role is to examine their report and compare their findings to the review key. Do not analyze the data yourself; treat the review key as the source of truth for this project. You will give the student one revision round if you identify any errors in their report. Do not tell them exactly what the error was, but hint at the general location of any errors. For example, if they didn’t account for a complication included in the data, you might ask them to double check that all their assumptions or valid, or to examine the data itself more closely. If their interpretation of the model is wrong, you might encourage them to review the meanings of the various model variables. The student will then revise their report and resubmit it to you, at which time you can reveal the information in the solution key, including which variables were meant to be included or excluded, the complication added to the data if one exists, and other important information from the review key. Note that it’s intentionally possible for the data generated to have a true effect, and yet fail to be significant due to random chance. This possibility is included to impress upon the student that random chance always plays a role in statistical analysis, and that their analysis could be completely correct, and yet fail to detect a true effect. If this is the case, you should mention this explicitly.

NoteUser · turn 0

Please find attached the orientation file, my report, the experimental design, and the dataset. How is my draft?

WarningAttachment placeholder

Four files were attached: the orientation file, the student report (student-report-1.html), the experimental design, and the dataset.

TipClaude · turn 1

I’ll read through your report first.

cd /home/claude && python3 -I -c "
import re,html,sys
s=open('/mnt/user-data/uploads/cbb9f45a-student-report-1.html').read()
s=re.sub(r'data:[^\"\')]+','DATA',s)
s=re.sub(r'(?is)<(script|style).*?</\1>','',s)
t=html.unescape(re.sub(r'<[^>]+>',' ',s))
t=re.sub(r'[ \t]+',' ',t); t=re.sub(r'\n\s*\n+','\n',t)
print(len(t)); print(t[:30000])
"; ls /mnt/user-data/uploads/
NoteUser · turn 2

Apologies, I forgot to attach the review key for comparison. Please take that into consideration when looking through the other materials.

WarningAttachment placeholder

One file was attached: the review key.

TipClaude · turn 3

Overall verdict

Your draft has no substantive errors, so you don’t need a revision round. Since that’s the case, I’ll go straight to what the review key says.

How your report compares to the key

Method. You chose ANCOVA, meaning a linear regression of QoR-15 on approach plus the baseline covariates. That’s the key’s preferred method. You also gave the right reason for it: a continuous outcome, a categorical treatment, and covariates that sharpen the estimate.

Variable decisions. All five match the key.

  • You included approach, age, BMI and diabetes because they were measured before surgery.
  • You excluded length_of_stay because it was measured after surgery and sits on the path between approach and recovery.

The planted complication. The data contained one deliberate trap: length of stay. It depends on the approach (laparoscopic patients go home about 2 days sooner) and on complications, which also lower QoR-15.

  • If you had adjusted for it, the approach effect would have dropped from about +6.6 to about −0.35, with p = 0.83. The real benefit would have disappeared completely.
  • You avoided the trap, and your explanation of why was correct.

Estimates. Your model is the intended one, and every number you report matches the key:

Term True value Your estimate 95% CI
Laparoscopic vs Open +7 +6.62 3.24 to 9.99
Age −0.25 −0.41 −0.58 to −0.23
BMI −0.40 −0.35 −0.71 to 0.001 (p = 0.050)
Diabetes (Yes) −5 −7.95 −11.99 to −3.90

Balance check. Your conclusion that randomization balanced the baseline covariates also matches the key’s expected findings.

About BMI

In the simulation that generated this data, BMI has a real effect: −0.4 points per kg/m². Your analysis just missed significance (p = 0.0503), and that was caused by random chance and limited power, not by a mistake on your part.

You handled it well. You didn’t claim an effect, and you didn’t call it evidence of no effect; you flagged it for a future study with more power. This is the main lesson of the exercise: a completely correct analysis can still fail to detect a true effect.

Minor polish (optional)

  • Levene’s test. A p-value of 0.015 is reasonable evidence that the variances differ, but “strong evidence” overstates it. Your follow-up, where you looked at the actual variance ratio of about 1.6, was the right instinct. A robust (HC3) standard error could serve as a quick sensitivity check.
  • Outliers. Scatterplots of the raw data are a weak test for this assumption. Residual diagnostics, such as standardized residuals or Cook’s distance, are the standard approach.
  • A possible extra. You could add a short sensitivity note showing that adding length_of_stay makes the approach effect vanish. That would make the case for excluding it with evidence, not just with reasoning.
  • Typos. “measure prior” should be “measured prior”, “use ANCOVA appropriate” should be “appropriately”, and “discrepency” should be “discrepancy”.

One limitation: when I pulled the text out of your report, the Shapiro–Wilk output and the plots came through garbled, so I couldn’t check those figures directly. Your conclusions from them are consistent with everything else in the report.

NoteUser · turn 4

Thank you for flagging the garbled output. Let me copy paste those tables directly.

Anova Table (Type III tests)

Response: qor15_30d
                   Sum Sq  Df  F value    Pr(>F)
(Intercept)       26665.9   1 183.9194 < 2.2e-16 ***
approach            171.2   1   1.1811 0.2785037
age                1654.2   1  11.4092 0.0008848 ***
bmi                 464.9   1   3.2062 0.0749351 .
diabetes            961.1   1   6.6291 0.0107854 *
approach:age         12.7   1   0.0875 0.7677488
approach:bmi         65.6   1   0.4526 0.5019198
approach:diabetes    18.4   1   0.1272 0.7217516
Residuals         27837.4 192
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
Analysis of Variance Table

Model 1: qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes
Model 2: qor15_30d ~ approach * age + approach * bmi + approach * diabetes
  Res.Df   RSS Df Sum of Sq      F Pr(>F)
1    195 27931
2    192 27837  3     93.11 0.2141 0.8866

    Shapiro-Wilk normality test

data:  res
W = 0.99684, p-value = 0.9582

Levene's Test for Homogeneity of Variance (center = median)
       Df F value  Pr(>F)
group   1  6.0145 0.01505 *
      198
---
Signif. codes:  0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1
approach      age      bmi diabetes
1.022815 1.014476 1.011044 1.006929
WarningImage placeholder

Q–Q plot of residuals, and age and BMI scatterplots with linear fits and dashed loess curves by approach.

TipClaude · turn 5

Thanks for sending those. I’ve now checked the parts I couldn’t see before, and they support your conclusions. My verdict doesn’t change.

Shapiro–Wilk (W = 0.997, p = 0.958). This gives no evidence against normal residuals, so “comfortably confirms” is reasonable. One small wording point: a non-significant normality test doesn’t prove normality. It means you found no departure from it. “Gives no evidence against normality” is the more precise phrasing.

Q–Q plot. The residuals follow the line closely and stay inside the confidence band all the way across, including both tails. There’s a slight wave near the centre, but it’s well within what you’d expect from 200 points. The plot backs up the Shapiro result, and it’s arguably the better evidence of the two. With n = 200, the plot is more informative than the test, so you could lead with it.

Age and BMI scatterplots.

  • Linearity: The dashed loess curves stay close to the straight lines over most of the range. The biggest gap is the laparoscopic loess curving upward below about age 45, but very few points support it. Loess always gets unstable at the edges where data are thin, so this isn’t real nonlinearity. You could add one sentence saying so, because a careful reader will notice that upturn.
  • Homogeneity of slopes: In both plots the two groups’ fitted lines run roughly parallel. That visually agrees with your interaction tests (p = 0.77 and 0.50).
  • The treatment effect is visible: The laparoscopic line sits above the open line along nearly the whole range. This matches your adjusted difference of about 6.6 points.
  • Outliers: Nothing sits far from the main cloud. The lowest scores, around 68–72, are spread across both groups and look like normal spread, not data errors. That fits the residual range in your model summary (about −34 to +34 with a residual SD of 12). Earlier I suggested adding a residual-based check such as Cook’s distance. That’s still worth including, but I’d expect it to confirm what you already concluded.

Interaction tests and VIFs. These match what was in the report.

Your assumption checks hold up. The only additions I’d make are the Shapiro wording tweak and a short note on the loess upturn at young ages.

Review key: Surgical approach and recovery after colectomy

Scenario colectomy-recovery, seed 81130, n = 200.

Accepted methods

  • Linear regression (ANCOVA) on QoR-15 with approach and baseline covariates (preferred): Baseline covariates improve precision; randomization already handles confounding.
  • Two-sample t-test (or Wilcoxon) comparing QoR-15 by approach (acceptable): Valid in a randomized trial, but less precise because baseline covariates are ignored.
  • Any model that includes length_of_stay as a covariate (flawed): Length of stay is a consequence of the approach; including it biases the approach estimate.

Variable decisions

Variable Decision Reason
approach include Randomized treatment of interest.
age include Measured before surgery; adjust for precision.
bmi include Measured before surgery; adjust for precision.
diabetes include Measured before surgery; adjust for precision.
length_of_stay exclude Measured after surgery and affected by the approach. It is part of how the approach affects recovery, not a baseline characteristic.

Wrinkles

  • A3_post_treatment: Length of stay is measured after surgery and depends on the approach (laparoscopic patients go home about 2 days sooner) and on complications, which also lower QoR-15. Adjusting for it distorts the approach effect.

Checks on this draw:

  • PASS (A3_post_treatment): length_of_stay differs across approach (|SMD| 1.09, need >= 0.2); adding it shifts approach by 4.07 SE (need >= 1.5)

Expected findings

  • Laparoscopic surgery improves QoR-15 by about 7 points.
  • Adding length_of_stay to the model shrinks or even reverses the approach effect.
  • Randomization balanced the baseline covariates.

This draw vs. the truth (outcome units)

Intended model: qor15_30d ~ approach + age + bmi + diabetes.

Term True Estimate 95% CI p Label
approach[Laparoscopic] 7 6.618 3.242 to 9.994 0.000151 detected
age -0.25 -0.406 -0.582 to -0.231 8.41e-06 detected
bmi -0.4 -0.354 -0.709 to 0.001 0.0503 MISSED: real effect not significant (limited power)
diabetes[Yes] -5 -7.948 -11.991 to -3.905 0.000144 detected

What the trap gives

Results a student would get by falling into the wrinkle, for comparison.

Model Term Estimate 95% CI p
adds length_of_stay approach[Laparoscopic] -0.354 -3.575 to 2.868 0.829

For the reveal

A correct analysis of this dataset will show the following, which differ from the truth by chance. Credit the analysis, then explain: - bmi: missed: real effect not significant (limited power).

Descriptive summaries

What an unadjusted or table-based analysis of this dataset shows.

approach (unadjusted one-way ANOVA p = 0.000221)

approach n mean sd
Open 100 100.29 11.63
Laparoscopic 100 107.25 14.38

diabetes (unadjusted one-way ANOVA p = 0.000561)

diabetes n mean sd
No 156 105.5 13.16
Yes 44 97.64 13.03

Balance across approach

Variable By group Max abs SMD
age Open: 64.02, Laparoscopic: 61.74 0.24
bmi Open: 28.84, Laparoscopic: 29.60 0.16
diabetes Open (% Yes): 0.20, Laparoscopic (% Yes): 0.24

How AI was used

In the design process, AI was used primarily to generate the datasets, experimental design descriptions, and review keys in the problem bank. Claude Opus 5.5 was asked to create a python program to generate data with a number of possible complications to the data as well as generating the text of a plausible associated experimental design. Claude was then used to check the dataset and ensure that any complication in the data are detectable. Then, Claude was used the generate a review key. The review key contains intended methods of analysis for the data based on the experimental design, a summary of the data, any included complications to the data and how that complication can influence the analysis if not handled, and the expected findings. This collection of experiments, datasets, and keys was then checked by a fresh instance of Claude Opus 5.5 to ensure accuracy.

Reflection

Overall, I’m happy with this project. I think it’s a good workflow for getting started with a new software while practicing a full cycle of statistical analysis. For taking this project to the next level, I think it would be interesting to make a larger framework around this project that can persistently track a student’s progress and adapt to their growth. This current project might be considered the easiest and most scaffolded, and we might increase the difficulty by adding multiple complications to the data, making the data messier and requiring cleaning as a first step, or by further restricting how much help the AI is allowed to give.

This might look like creating a webpage, similar to the pharmacy calculations practice app, that tracks the student’s uploaded projects and “grades” each one, increasing the difficulty of future tasks as appropriate. This has a number of potential issues in implementation, particularly with how AI would be implemented into the web page itself and how usage would be kept reasonable.

Another possibility for implementing a persistent memory of student progress would be simply to have the AI revise and output a document at the end of each stage 2 that records each experiment and summarizes any issues with the student’s report. The AI orientation documents could be revised to reference this progress document. This potential approach seems promising for keeping the project lightweight and portable, but we do run into some potential issues for how the student is actually given their harder datasets. It might be necessary to have the stage 1 AI generate the data itself from the Python program directly. This loses out on the testing and partitioned stages, though, so it’s less than ideal. It might necessitate a three stage workflow, where the initial stage is to have the AI generate and check the data, and then move that into the usual stage 1 and stage 2 workflow.